Writers as Readers
Learning from colleagues
November 2026


Stephen King once recommended, “If you want to be a writer, you must do two things above all others: read a lot and write a lot.” I’ve been taking his advice lately, reading all kinds of speculative fiction—high and urban fantasies, as well as some romantasies.
While these sub-genres overlap, they are very different beasts. Epic or high fantasy stories weave elaborate story worlds with an adventurous journey for the hero/ine on an external and internal quest. Urban fantasy sprinkles magic into a contemporary setting where a mystery is solved or evil confronted. In both, romance may be a secondary subplot.
In contrast, romantasy focuses on the love interest between characters as the central theme, set in either urban or epic fantasy worlds. Magical elements have a place, but never overwhelm the romance. This sub-genre often heats up the love interest to be a lot more spicy than my preference.
That being said, I’m truly amazed how I can barely make it through some novels, while the majority of reviews sound like the following (for a romantasy):
OMG ITS SOOOOOO GOOD!!!!!! I am addicted! I was on such a hangover from this book.
My top read of 2025 !! Fantastic!!
One of the best books I’ve ever read. Hands down!
There were a few (and I mean three out of nearly 600) who agreed with me:
It seems like a good story but holy moly, is it slowwww. I think the first book is a lot of world building and some action, but nothing really happens I was not in a rush to read the 2nd book.
I DNF'd it. The FMC's inner monologue was insufferable. All she did was ask questions to herself and no one else and it was a struggle to get through.
Unpopular opinion here 😬 it was good but I found it to be very repetitive with her thoughts.
Doesn’t sound like the same book, does it? Clearly, readers’ tastes vary widely. While I might struggle with the writing style, others ignore the slow plot, insufferable monologue, or repetitiveness while they lose themselves in the romance.
In the meantime, I’ve learned a few lessons from taking Mr. King’s counsel. First, reading others’ work provides insights, even if it’s simply what to avoid in my own writing. Second, authors cannot please everyone with their novels—someone will always write a scathing review no matter how many copies sell.
And finally, it’s important to not let criticism crush one’s soul. A review is one person’s opinion, not a measure of self-worth. It can actually give hope to novice writers when a book seems subpar, perhaps providing encouragement that they too can get their work in progress published someday.
Keep the faith!
